
Beyond Spaghetti Testing: Building a Customer-Centric AB Testing Strategy
Many companies approach conversion rate optimization (CRO) with enthusiasm but without a coherent strategy. They collect random ideas from blog posts promising "100 Conversion Rate Hacks" or copy what they see on popular websites. This approach—which Nils aptly calls "spaghetti testing" (throwing ideas at the wall to see what sticks)—leads to fragmented learning and minimal sustainable growth.
The fundamental issue with this approach is that even when tests succeed, companies rarely learn anything meaningful about their customers. After a typical three-month pilot phase with 12 tests, a company might see some conversion improvements but gain little insight into why certain changes worked while others failed.
Moving Beyond Best Practices
Best practices are problematic because they:
- Aren't tailored to your specific customers' problems
- Don't acknowledge that no two shops are identical—even within the same industry
- Don't address why customers behave the way they do
As Jan Marx, VWO Europe Lead, pointed out during the webinar: "Nine out of ten companies that engage with conversion optimization eventually realize they had no effective AB testing strategy."
.jpg)
A/B-Testing Strategie für mehr Umsatz (Webinar-Leak)
Video is in German – you can turn on english subtitles.
The Real Goal: Learning About Your Customers
The webinar emphasized that while growth is important, sustainable growth comes from customer-centric optimization. This means shifting focus from metrics like conversion rate to understanding and solving actual customer problems.
Nils outlined three key areas where effective AB testing strategies can deliver value:
1. Understanding the "Why"
- Does a change impact purchase motivation?
- Does it make completing a purchase easier?
- Does it solve a specific customer problem?
2. Understanding the "How"
- What does the ideal customer journey look like for different customer segments?
- How do customers navigate through decision points?
3. Continuous Improvement
- With each test, how can we gain deeper insights that inform future optimizations?
- How can we build upon our understanding with each iteration?
A Framework for Customer-Centric Testing
Nils proposed a systematic approach to developing a customer-centric AB testing strategy:
Step 1: Understand Your Customers Through Research
Instead of immediately implementing best practices, invest time in:
- Analyzing customer reviews
- Gathering feedback from customer support teams
- Conducting heatmap analysis and session recordings
- Scientific research relevant to your product's use cases
Jan highlighted that this research comes in two forms:
- Observations: Unstructured insights gathered by team members across the organization
- Focused Research: Deliberate analysis of specific behaviors or friction points
Step 2: Identify and Cluster Customer Problems
Transform research insights into clearly defined customer problems. For example, if selling mattresses, customer problems might include:
- Back pain relief
- Replacing an old mattress
- Price sensitivity
- Durability concerns
Once identified, cluster similar problems together to form a cohesive testing framework.
Step 3: Create Behavioral Hypotheses
Instead of disconnected test ideas (the "Swiss cheese" approach), develop overarching behavioral hypotheses tied to specific customer problems.
For instance, rather than testing random trust elements, develop a hypothesis like: "Customers with back problems need specific information about how our mattress alleviates pain points to feel confident in their purchase."
Step 4: Test Systematically Within These "Containers"
Organize individual test ideas within these behavioral hypothesis "containers." This allows you to:
- Evaluate which customer problems are most important to solve
- Build a cohesive understanding of customer behavior
- Share insights across teams (marketing, creative, customer service)
Step 5: Document and Analyze Patterns
Maintain thorough documentation of:
- Research insights
- Customer problems
- Test hypotheses
- Results and learnings
This allows for meta-analysis across multiple tests to identify which behavioral hypotheses consistently deliver results.
Finding the Right Research Balance
A common question addressed during the webinar was about balancing research with action. Nils recommended:
- Starting with a heuristic analysis to identify obvious issues
- Beginning testing immediately with experience-based "big bets"
- Simultaneously conducting structured research with time allocations for different methods
- Allocating roughly 50% of initial time to research and 50% to testing
Key Takeaways
- Question best practices: Consider whether they actually solve your customers' unique problems
- Invest in research: Understand customer behavior before jumping to solutions
- Structure tests around customer problems: Move from random testing to a cohesive framework
- Document everything: Create a system for capturing insights, hypotheses, and results
- Think beyond individual tests: Use meta-analysis to identify patterns across multiple experiments
By adopting this strategic, customer-centric approach to AB testing, companies can move beyond short-term conversion lifts to achieve sustainable growth based on a deep understanding of customer needs and behaviors.
More resources
If you liked these resources, check out these other resources.